Lake El Estero Got Its Permission Slip. Now It Needs $30,000.

Nancy Nino | November 5, 2026

Walk past the boat dock at 798 Del Monte Boulevard this fall and the swan boats are tied up. A sign posted by El Estero Boating, a business founded in 1966, put the problem plainly when the Carmel Pine Cone's Kelly Nix reported on it September 4: the city had not maintained Lake El Estero for two years, the business had closed, and four employees had been laid off. The lake was choked with widgeon grass. The paddleboats could not move through it.

For most of the year, the City of Monterey's answer was a permit. Parks and Recreation Director Nicole Banks told the Pine Cone in September that the city had begun applying to the California Department of Fish and Wildlife the year before, and that it expected the process to take about a year.

In mid-October, the state waived the permit. The boats are still tied up. The claim of this post is small. The thing standing between Monterey and an open lake is no longer paperwork. It is a line in a budget that is $11.7 million short.

What Grows in a Lake That Breathes Through a Pipe

Lake El Estero is not quite a lake. A city-commissioned memo by Rincon Consultants, dated August 11, describes it as connected to Monterey Bay through pipe culverts, and identifies the plant as widgeon grass, Ruppia maritima, which tolerates brackish water. The memo notes the grass can interfere with pump intakes and aeration equipment as well as boats. By October, Nix reported, widgeon grass and algae had spread across the lake and the water often smelled.

The city's plan is modest. A Notice of Exemption filed with the state on August 12 and signed by Community Development Director Kimberly Cole describes mechanical removal using specialized harvesting equipment that cuts and collects vegetation above the lakebed without disturbing the sediment, with the stated purpose of restoring safe recreational use, including paddleboat operations. The Rincon memo also notes the project site is not within the coastal zone. The Pine Cone reported the estimated cost at about $30,000, and that the city would seek bids.

That is the scale of the fix. Not a dredge, not a restoration plan. A cutting machine and a contractor.

It is also the scale of what is being lost. El Estero Boating's own price list, still posted on its site under a banner reading temporarily closed, runs from $25 for half an hour in a standard paddleboat to $40 for the swans and ducks and $45 for the dragon boats. The city stocks the lake for fishing several times a year. For families in Downtown, Oak Grove and the blocks along Camino Aguajito, this is the neighborhood's backyard, and this summer, normally the concession's busiest season, the most recognizable part of it sat closed.

The Permit Was the Reason Until It Wasn't

The city's case, through the summer, was that it could not cut without state approval. Even the August memo assumed a Fish and Wildlife lake or streambed alteration agreement would be needed. Then, in the week of the October 16 Pine Cone story, the state said it was not.

Banks put it this way: "After ongoing consultation and their review of our application, we are happy to share that they are allowing us to proceed with weed harvesting without requiring a permit. This was the city's desired outcome all along, but ultimately, we required California Department of Fish and Wildlife permission."

She was less specific about when. "I can't give a timeframe for the work until we are further along in this process," she said, adding that the city was preparing bid documents and working to see if and when a funding source would be available.

"I can't give a timeframe for the work until we are further along in this process."

The business's account is harder. At the October 6 City Council meeting, co-owner Cathy Giammanco said El Estero Boating had lost more than $150,000 this year and more than $120,000 last year, and was closed through its busiest season. "We have asked the city for rent relief, but we've heard nothing," she said. The city's position, per Banks in September, is that the lease does not provide for routine grass cutting, but does allow a temporary rent reduction if an inspection confirms vegetation is unreasonably impeding the business. Whether that relief has been granted was not reported as of the end of October.

A $30,000 Job in an $11.7 Million Hole

The reason a five-figure contract cannot simply be signed is on the city's own Roadmap to Resilience page: Monterey has an $11.7 million structural budget deficit. The adopted 2026-27 budget, as Aric Sleeper reported in Monterey County Now in June, froze 30 vacant positions to save about $4.6 million and moved $3.5 million out of the Neighborhood Community Improvement Project fund into the general fund. The city's page also makes a point residents often miss: cities in Monterey County receive, on average, only about 6 percent of the property tax their residents pay.

That is the context for every deferred item in Monterey right now, and the lake is a visible one. It sits at the center of the 45-acre El Estero Park Complex, bounded by Del Monte, Camino Aguajito, Fremont and Camino El Estero, along with the Dennis the Menace Playground, Sollecito Ballpark, the skate park, a dog park, fishing piers and a 1.2-mile exercise course. Most of that still works. The water is the part that doesn't.

The city has scheduled a way for residents to weigh in, and the location is apt. A Budget Resilience Workshop is set for Monday, November 16, at 6 p.m. at El Estero Park Center, 777 Pearl Street, a short walk from the dock. Smaller drop-in sessions the city calls Budget Brews run November 7 at La Sala's Bi-Rite Market, November 19 at the Starbucks on Lighthouse Avenue, and December 8 at Nece's GF Bakery. Engagement runs through December 8, with the next budget due for adoption in June 2027.

What This Means If You're Comparing Monterey Neighborhoods

A closed paddleboat concession is not a market event, and the numbers confirm it. MLSListings put the September single-family median for 93940 at $1,247,500, down 12.8 percent, on 18 sales, which is a mix effect in a month that small. Redfin's figure for the period labeled June was $1,154,739 on 78 sales, up 1.7 percent, with homes selling at about 98 percent of list. Recent condo escrows near the park include a unit on Casanova Avenue at $485,000 and one on Glenwood Circle at $560,000.

What the lake does show is how to read the city's service level, which is the variable worth watching while the deficit is being closed:

  • Look at what the city maintains near the address. Parks, medians, lakes and trees are where deferred maintenance shows first. A home a block from El Estero is a different daily experience with the boats running than without.
  • Separate restricted money from the general fund. Street repair has its own dedicated tax. Park maintenance competes with police, fire and everything else in a general fund that is short.
  • Watch the November and December sessions. The Roadmap to Resilience will set priorities for the 2027-28 budget. The list that comes out of it is a better guide to neighborhood upkeep than any median price.
  • Ask what is on a deferred list near the property. The city does not always publish one, but staff will usually tell you what is waiting.

The permit is gone. The machine exists. The lake is still green. In Monterey this year, the distance between a decision and a result is usually measured in dollars, and in this case it is about thirty thousand of them.

A Few Questions Worth Asking Directly

When will Lake El Estero be cleaned up?

No date has been set. The city's parks director said in mid-October that staff were preparing bid documents and looking for a funding source, and would not give a timeframe. El Estero Boating's website says it may reopen around November if rain kills off the grass.

Why did it take so long?

The city said it needed a California Department of Fish and Wildlife permit and expected that process to take about a year. In October the agency waived the requirement. The remaining step is bidding and funding the roughly $30,000 removal job.

Is the rest of El Estero Park open?

Yes. The skate park, dog park, fishing piers, ballpark and exercise course remain open. Dennis the Menace Playground is closed on non-holiday Tuesdays between Labor Day and Memorial Day.

Where can residents raise this with the city?

At the Budget Resilience Workshop on November 16 at 6 p.m. at El Estero Park Center, 777 Pearl Street, or at the Budget Brews drop-ins on November 7, November 19 and December 8.

Does the lake's condition affect home values nearby?

Not in any figure that can be measured. Monterey's medians move on which homes happen to sell in a given month. What the lake shows is how the city is prioritizing maintenance while it closes an $11.7 million deficit, which is worth weighing for any address near a park.

Nancy Nino of Carmel Luxury Group watches Monterey's budget sessions as closely as its listings, because the parks, medians and lake a city can afford to maintain are part of what a neighborhood is. If you are weighing a home near El Estero, Downtown or Oak Grove, start a confidential consultation with Nancy and ask what the city has deferred nearby.


Nancy Nino
Team Leader, Carmel Luxury Group | Coldwell Banker Realty
[email protected] | 831.277.0405
CA DRE# 02168301

Work With Us

Their industry specialities include luxury homes, relocations, estate sales and investment properties. With 16 years of experience in the real estate industry, she has been through multiple market cycles as an agent, buyer and investor, and has a deep understanding for the often-complicated process that her clients will encounter.

Contact Us

Follow Us On Instagram