Pull up the City of Monterey's water availability page and the first sentence does the work: the City "does not have water credits available for allocation." That line has been true in one form or another since October 20, 2009, when the State Water Board adopted Order WR 2009-0060 against California American Water and, in Condition 2, barred Cal Am from diverting Carmel River water for new service connections. No new meters. A vacant lot in Monterey, Pacific Grove, Carmel, Seaside, Sand City, Del Rey Oaks or the Cal Am parts of Carmel Valley has been a lot you could own but not build on, unless water credits already sat on the parcel.
On November 5, 2026, the State Water Board holds a public comment day on whether to change that. For the first time since the order was issued, Cal Am itself is not objecting.
Who Asked, and What They Asked For
The Monterey Peninsula Water Management District filed the application on October 21, 2025, after a unanimous board vote the day before. The ask is specific: rescind Condition 2, keep the quarterly and annual reporting, and add a trigger. If Cal Am reports Carmel River diversions above 3,376 acre-feet in any water year, which is Cal Am's lawful limit, the moratorium comes back immediately without another Board action.
The district's case rests on numbers that have moved since 2009. Pure Water Monterey's expansion came online October 10, 2025, adding 2,250 acre-feet a year; the district says the project now supplies 60 percent of the Peninsula's drinking water. The CPUC confirmed in August 2025 that Peninsula supply exceeds 11,000 acre-feet a year. Demand in the water year that ended September 30, 2025 was 9,092 acre-feet, and the five-year average is 9,245. Cal Am has stayed inside its river right since 2021.
Dave Stoldt, the district's general manager, put the argument to Monterey County Now in one line: "We've got to move this book off the fiction shelf to the reference shelf."
Cal Am's Turn, and the Catch Inside It
Cal Am's December 2025 letter asked the Board to deny the application or hold it. Then on August 19, 2026, the company issued a release from Pacific Grove announcing it had filed testimony supporting "a temporary suspension of the moratorium on new connections." Its president, Sarah Leeper, said the company "can support a temporary suspension of the moratorium on new water connections to allow more flexibility for the community while maintaining key protections for the Carmel River," and in the same release that "Any modification to the cease-and-desist order must consider Monterey Peninsula's unique water supply constraints."
The catch is in the word temporary. According to Sara Rubin's September 3 reporting in Monterey County Now, Cal Am's August 20 testimony by senior manager David Pezzini asks that any suspension run only until July 1, 2030, and only if its desalination plant is online by then. Cal Am expects the plant operational by the end of 2029. The Carmel Pine Cone's Kelly Nix reported on August 28 that Stoldt called a temporary suspension a "silly idea" that "makes no sense."
So the two parties who matter most now agree the ban should lift, and disagree on the shape of the door. The district wants it open with a tripwire. Cal Am wants it open with a timer tied to desal.
"We've got to move this book off the fiction shelf to the reference shelf."
The Calendar, Exactly
The hearing notice, amended July 9, 2026 after Cal Am objected to the original schedule, set written testimony for August 19, rebuttal for September 18, public comment and policy statements for November 5 (in person at the CalEPA Building in Sacramento or by Zoom), and closing briefs of no more than ten pages by November 10. Senior Hearing Officer Megan Knize presides. As of the notice, the Division had received 34 letters on the application.
Public comment on November 5 is about five minutes per speaker and is not evidence. After closing briefs, staff and the hearing officer prepare a draft order, which goes out for its own public comment before the Board takes it up at a regular meeting. The district's July 20 board minutes record Stoldt saying "a decision is expected after the first of the year."
The City of Monterey is on the record. The council voted 4-1 on November 18, 2025 to send a letter urging the Board to lift the order. A July 2025 letter from Mayor Tyller Williamson to the CPUC put the city's 2023 to 2031 housing target at 3,654 units, with reliable future supply "approaching 12,000 acre-feet per year" and current demand "remaining under 9,000 AFY."
What Does Not Change on November 5, or After
This is the part that gets lost in the headline. Nothing about the hearing alters the water permit rules that govern an existing house.
An MPWMD water permit is still what allows you to get a building permit and set a meter, or to intensify use on an existing connection, and it is still required to change a meter size. Monterey's Ordinance 98 still governs bathrooms: a single-family home can add a second full bath without a City allocation, a home with one and a half baths can add only a half bath, and two full baths is the ceiling. Fixtures are counted in units; a standard tub-and-shower bath is two, a separate tub and shower is four.
ADUs follow the same water permit process, with an instant-access hot water system required as a condition and no credit given for it. Adding a bathroom requires every toilet on the site at 1.28 gallons per flush and showerheads at 2.0 gallons per minute, with no credit for required retrofits. Water use credits documented when efficient fixtures replace old ones expire after ten years.
And the resale rules under Rule 141 do not move. A change of ownership triggers retrofit certification: high-efficiency toilets, 2.0 gpm showerheads, 1.2 gpm bath faucets, 1.8 gpm kitchen faucets. The seller normally does the work unless the buyer agrees to and notifies the district, in which case the buyer has six months after title transfer, extendable by six more. A Notice of Non-Compliance can be recorded on title. An open permit usually means a prior owner never got a final inspection.
What This Means If You Are Buying in the Cal Am Service Area
The honest framing for a buyer this fall is that the moratorium is likely to be suspended, not simply lifted, and with a mechanism that can bring it back. Price today's purchase on today's rules.
- A vacant lot is still a lot without a meter until the Board acts and a draft order survives its own comment period. Do not pay for buildability that does not exist yet. If credits sit on the parcel, get the MPWMD documentation before the offer.
- A remodel that stays inside Ordinance 98 and the existing connection is unaffected. A remodel that needs a larger meter or more fixture units than the credits support is waiting on the same hearing the lot is.
- Ask which version of relief you are betting on. Under the district's proposal, the ban returns the moment Cal Am exceeds 3,376 acre-feet in a year. Under Cal Am's, relief expires July 1, 2030 unless desal is running.
- Budget the retrofit. Rule 141 applies to every closing in the district regardless of what Sacramento decides.
The fiction shelf line is good because it is true. The Peninsula has more water than its rules admit. Whether the rules catch up in January, or in 2030, is the question a November 5 hearing in Sacramento will start to answer.
A Few Questions Worth Asking Directly
Can I buy a vacant lot in Monterey and build on it right now? Not on a new Cal Am meter. Condition 2 of the 2009 order still bars new connections, and the City has no water credits to allocate. Only credits already attached to the parcel can be used, and you should see MPWMD's documentation of them before you write an offer.
Can I add a bathroom to an existing house? Usually one. Monterey's Ordinance 98 allows a second full bath without a City allocation, with two full baths as the maximum, and the addition needs an MPWMD water permit with fixture retrofits across the house. This does not depend on the hearing.
When would the ban actually lift? Public comment is November 5, closing briefs are due November 10, and then a draft order goes out for comment before a Board vote. MPWMD's general manager told his board a decision is expected after the first of the year. Cal Am's version would end any suspension on July 1, 2030 unless desal is online.
Is there really enough water? Supply is above 11,000 acre-feet a year by the CPUC's August 2025 finding, against 9,092 acre-feet of demand in the 2025 water year. The dispute is about the future: the CPUC adopted Cal Am's 2050 demand figure of 13,732 acre-feet, which is the basis for the desal plant.
Do the resale retrofit rules change? No. Rule 141 still requires fixture certification at every change of ownership in the district, with the seller normally responsible and a six-month window for a buyer who takes it on.
Nancy Nino of Carmel Luxury Group reads the water permit file on a property before she reads the listing remarks, because on this Peninsula the meter decides what a lot is worth. If you are weighing a vacant parcel, an ADU, or a remodel anywhere in the Cal Am service area, start a confidential consultation with Nancy and bring the APN.
Nancy Nino
Team Leader, Carmel Luxury Group | Coldwell Banker Realty
[email protected] | 831.277.0405
CA DRE# 02168301