Monterey County has approved vacation rental applications in Pebble Beach. Pebble Beach Company, which owns the roads, has objected to short-term rentals since 2024 and says it will not grant permission for rental guests to use its private roads.
The gap between the county's approvals and the company's objection is a central part of the short-term rental debate in Del Monte Forest right now.
Monterey County's Vacation Rental Rules
Monterey County's vacation rental rules sort rentals into three categories: homestays, limited vacation rentals and commercial vacation rentals. The county caps only the commercial category, and it sets the cap by planning area. The inland rules took effect October 14, 2024. Pebble Beach is in the coastal zone, so it waited for the California Coastal Commission, which approved the county's approach in August 2025, according to Monterey County NOW. The Monterey Herald reported that the Board of Supervisors finalized the coastal regulations that September.
County rules cover commercial vacation rental caps, fees and applications:
- Permit caps. The county's table allows 57 commercial vacation rental use permits under the Del Monte Forest Land Use Plan. The Carmel Area Land Use Plan allows 118, and the Big Sur Coast allows none.
- License fees. The county lists a Vacation Rental Operation License fee of $965, or $1,152.40 with related charges. A well or septic system can add a $301 Environmental Health fee. Transient occupancy tax, a business license and the land use entitlement for a commercial rental are all extra.
- Applications and appeals. The Zoning Administrator decides each application. Neighbors can appeal to the Board of Supervisors.
The Company That Owns the Roads Has Objected
Pebble Beach Company issued a blanket objection to short-term rentals in 2024, soon after the county passed its ordinances. The company bases its position on covenants, conditions and restrictions in Del Monte Forest, which it reads as barring commercial use. Diane Goldman, the company's general counsel, put the position plainly in a letter to the county that Monterey County NOW quoted:
"The plain meaning of the CC&R language bans short-term vacation rentals in the Del Monte Forest. Arguments to the contrary are entirely unpersuasive."
The county has kept approving applications anyway, because it treats the CC&Rs as a separate legal question. Housing and Community Development staff told protesting neighbors that their complaints had no standing in the permit process, because staff were following county rules and the CC&Rs are a civil matter.
Party | Role | Their position, as of October 2026 |
|---|---|---|
Monterey County Zoning Administrator | Whether a qualifying application is approved | Has approved qualifying Pebble Beach applications |
Monterey County Board of Supervisors | Appeals and future ordinance changes | Denied four neighbor appeals 5-0 on October 20 |
Pebble Beach Company | Its private roads | Says it will not grant permission for rental guests to use its roads |
Four Licenses and a 5-0 Vote
The October 20 hearing showed how the arrangement works in practice. Neighbors asked the Board of Supervisors to overturn four licenses the Zoning Administrator had already approved. The supervisors voted 5-0 to deny the appeals. Monterey County NOW reported that the board considered itself bound by the ordinances it had adopted. Supervisor Kate Daniels, whose district includes Pebble Beach, said before the first vote that "it would be wonderful if it could be determined in a court of law." One applicant at the hearing told the board that a civil hearing was where the matter needed to go.
According to the same NOW report, the licenses last seven years.
For an August 13, 2026 hearing, a county staff report recommended approving one application and said that, if approved, it would be the fourth permitted vacation rental in Del Monte Forest. The cap for commercial rentals there is 57. NOW counted seven approved licenses by its October report. So most of the permit capacity is unused.
Why Rentals Are Still Operating
Visitors to Pebble Beach can still find rentals online. In its October report, Monterey County NOW counted more than 20 Pebble Beach vacation rentals listed on online platforms. Some were operating illegally. Others were still in the application process. In August, NOW reported that one of the first approved homes was advertised on VRBO at more than $1,300 a night for late August, without road permission from Pebble Beach Company.
Rates like that explain why owners keep applying. The neighbors' testimony explains why the appeals keep coming. As NOW reported from the October hearing, residents told supervisors about loud parties, many vehicles and extra traffic, and trash bins left out for days, and they asked the county for more enforcement. At an earlier appeal hearing on July 7, a Sunset Lane resident described at least five short-term rentals on one block under the previous rules. Daniels asked for a continuance so the board could understand the CC&Rs and the private-road question. "If we don't, we're going to have this same appeal play out over and over and over again," she said, as NOW reported.
For a buyer, this cuts both ways. A home next to an active rental feels different from a home on a quiet cul-de-sac.
The Rules Are Still Changing This Winter
County staff acknowledged at the October hearing that the ordinances contain no specific language letting the Zoning Administrator consider clustering, meaning several rentals located close together. The Planning Commission reviewed the vacation rental ordinances on October 28, and the Board of Supervisors is expected to take them up in December. Daniels said she wants that December meeting to "address clustering and density in a way that would empower the zoning administrator to consider [them] in their decisions."
A separate lawsuit is also affecting the rules countywide. In Monterey County Vacation Rental Alliance v. County of Monterey, Superior Court Case No. 24CV004922, rulings led the county to stop enforcing two provisions. One treated non-resident homestay owners differently from residents. The other treated corporate and other entity owners differently from individual owners, for every type of vacation rental. The county's vacation rental page says the litigation is ongoing and that future rulings or amendments could change what can be enforced.
The full ordinance text is public: the Vacation Rental Operation License, Chapter 7.120, and the coastal regulations, Ordinance No. 5439.
Quick Answers
How many commercial vacation rentals does the county allow in Del Monte Forest? The county's planning-area table sets 57 commercial vacation rental use permits for the Del Monte Forest Land Use Plan. Homestays and limited vacation rentals have no countywide cap.
Where can I see which homes are approved or pending? The county keeps a vacation rental mapping application that shows approved and pending rentals in unincorporated Monterey County.
This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. CC&R questions and rental plans should be reviewed with your own attorney and advisors.
If you're weighing a Pebble Beach second home, Carmel Luxury Group can walk you through the property, its street and its price. Start a confidential consultation.