The City of Monterey publishes a number for every neighborhood that most buyers never see. It is called a Pavement Condition Index, a score from zero to 100 for the streets you drive on, and the January 12, 2026 update reads like a disclosure. Old Town and Skyline Forest sit at 86. Monterey Vista and Alta Mesa are at 82. New Monterey and Glenwood are at 79. Downtown is 73. Del Monte Beach is 70. Deer Flats is 65. Skyline Ridge is 58.
Citywide, that score was 54 in 2013, which the city's own scale calls "At Risk." Today it is 79, which the scale calls "Good." The money that moved it is a one-cent sales tax that Monterey voters first approved in 2014 and renewed in 2018, and that expires on March 31, 2027 unless Measure S passes on November 3.
That is the whole measure. It is not a tax increase. It does not touch the city's operating deficit. It is a question about whether the number next to your neighborhood keeps going up.
What the Ballot Actually Says
The council adopted Resolution 26-103 on July 21, 2026, unanimously, and the county assigned the letter S. The ballot question is long but the operative phrase is "without increasing tax rates." The measure renews "the existing one-cent per dollar sales tax for 8 years," moving the expiration from March 31, 2027 to March 31, 2035, "providing $12 million annually, requiring public disclosure of funds/independent audits, and all funds spent locally."
City Attorney M. Christine Davi's impartial analysis, dated August 3, states the current combined rate: "State and local tax on retail sales in the City of Monterey is currently 9.25% of the purchase price, of which the City of Monterey receives 2.5% of the revenue." A yes vote keeps 9.25 percent. A no vote means "the existing tax would no longer be collected after March 31, 2027," and the rate falls by a penny.
Because the money is restricted to streets, sidewalks, storm drains and accessibility work, Measure S is a special tax and needs two-thirds to pass. Its predecessor, Measure P, passed in 2014 with 74 percent. The 2018 renewal passed with 82 percent.
Where the Money Has Gone Since 2013
The city's July 29, 2026 progress release is unusually concrete. Since the program started: 1,012 street segments repaired, with 90 more under construction or out to bid; roughly 87 centerline miles and 13.8 million square feet of pavement; $7.5 million in sidewalk repairs; $6 million in storm drain upgrades; 375 ADA ramps; 21 signalized intersections. The January 2026 graphic puts it another way: Monterey has 1,271 street segments, and 1,018 of them, 78.5 percent, have been maintained since 2013.
The city says its other street money, gas tax and SB1 funds, comes to under $2 million a year against the $5 million to $6 million it needs annually to keep roads in good repair. Mayor Tyller Williamson's line in the July release addresses who pays: "Given how many visitors we attract to Monterey, 62% of this sales tax is paid by non-residents."
The February 2026 project map lists what is queued: Wave Street ADA and pavement rehabilitation, Cass and El Dorado, North Fremont, Aly's Alley, and a 2026 package covering Aguajito Road, Garden Road and Ryan Ranch Road, plus citywide resurfacing that includes Lower Ragsdale Drive and Mark Thomas Drive. The rebuttal to the argument against, signed by Williamson, former Mayor Clyde Roberson, Councilmember Jean Rasch and oversight committee members, adds the Lake El Estero storm water pump station, "estimated at over $3 million," and "extensive street reconstructions on major thoroughfares like Foam and Franklin Streets."
If the measure passes, the city's August mailer says the split is roughly 35 percent streets, 20 percent ADA accessibility, 7 percent sidewalks, 7 percent storm drains, with the remaining 31 percent going to local priorities across those categories.
The Deficit Is a Different Problem
Here is where a reader can get the two Monterey money stories tangled. The city has an operating deficit. City Manager Dante Hall said it plainly in the August 18 release: "We currently face a $12 million structural budget deficit." The FY 2026-27 budget adopted June 16 ran about $114 million in revenue against $126 million in expenditures, and the council closed the gap without touching reserves by freezing 30 vacant positions worth $4.6 million, among them two police officers, three firefighters and a traffic engineer, and by transferring $3.5 million from the neighborhood improvement fund.
Measure S cannot fix that. Its money is legally walled off for infrastructure. The deficit is being addressed through a separate program the city calls Roadmap to Resilience, presented to the council on August 18, with neighborhood workshops running through December and drop-in sessions at places like Monterey Donuts, East Village Coffee and Plumes.
The reason this matters for Measure S is the June 2 election. Measure D, a 0.375 percent general tax for the general fund, failed by 153 votes. On June 24 the council voted 5-0 to drop proposed parking and vacant-home taxes and put only the Measure S renewal on the November ballot. A June poll by FM3 of about 400 residents found 73 percent yes on the renewal.
"Without increasing tax rates, shall the City of Monterey measure to fix streets, potholes, and sidewalks..."
The argument against, signed by Laurence Friese, Michelle Patric, James Patric and Lori Mazzuca, does not dispute the street results. It asks, in capitals, "MEASURE S SAYS IT WILL FIX SIDEWALKS. WHICH ONES?" and argues that "When City Hall paints an orange line and requires a repair, homeowners must personally pay to fix the adjoining public sidewalk, while continuing to pay a tax that funds sidewalk repairs." The rebuttal's answer: "State and City law have consistently held homeowners responsible for sidewalk repairs," and the tax has funded high-traffic corridors, ADA ramps and damage from city trees.
What This Means If You Are Comparing Monterey Neighborhoods
Read the PCI table the way you would read a roof inspection.
- The lowest scores are Skyline Ridge at 58, Deer Flats at 65, Del Monte Beach at 70 and Downtown at 73. Those are the neighborhoods where the next eight years of Measure S money would do the most visible work, and where a no vote would show first.
- Old Town, Skyline Forest, Casanova Oak Knoll and Villa Del Monte are at 84 or better. The program has largely reached them. A buyer there is paying for maintenance, not catch-up.
- Walk the sidewalk in front of the house, not just the street. The sidewalk is the homeowner's responsibility under city and state law regardless of the measure, and the argument against cites new fees effective July 1, 2026 for required sidewalk repairs. Those figures come from the opposition argument and should be confirmed against the city fee schedule, but the principle is not in dispute.
- Separate the two money stories in your own underwriting. The infrastructure fund is healthy and restricted. The general fund is in deficit and the fix is a multi-year plan. Service levels, not street quality, are the thing to watch there.
The market has not been reading any of this. MLSListings puts the September 2026 single-family median for 93940 at $1,247,500 on 43 active listings, down 12.8 percent year over year, which on one month in a market this size is a mix number and nothing more. Redfin's three-month median through June was $1,154,739 on 78 sales, up 1.7 percent. Neither figure knows which block has a PCI of 58.
A Few Questions Worth Asking Directly
Does Measure S raise my sales tax? No. It continues the existing one cent, keeping the combined rate at 9.25 percent. If it fails, the rate drops by one cent after March 31, 2027 and the city loses roughly $12 million a year in restricted infrastructure money.
Can the city spend Measure S money on the deficit? No. It is a special tax limited to streets, sidewalks, storm drains and ADA improvements, with a citizens' oversight committee and annual audits. The $11.7 million general fund deficit is a separate problem handled through the Roadmap to Resilience.
Which Monterey neighborhoods have the worst streets? By the city's January 2026 index: Skyline Ridge 58, Deer Flats 65, Del Monte Beach 70, Downtown 73. The best are Old Town and Skyline Forest at 86.
Who fixes the sidewalk in front of my house? The homeowner, under state and city law, according to the city's rebuttal. Measure S has funded sidewalk work on high-traffic corridors and ADA ramps, not every residential frontage.
What happened to Measure D in June? A 0.375 percent general tax for the general fund failed on June 2 by 153 votes. The council then dropped other new-tax ideas and put only the Measure S renewal on the November ballot.
Nancy Nino of Carmel Luxury Group reads the city's street index and the project map before showing a Monterey home, because the pavement outside a house is part of what you are buying. If you are weighing Skyline Forest against Del Monte Beach, or a downtown condo against a house in Deer Flats, start a confidential consultation with Nancy and ask what the street in front of it scored.
Nancy Nino
Team Leader, Carmel Luxury Group | Coldwell Banker Realty
[email protected] | 831.277.0405
CA DRE# 02168301